Joe’s harsh reality check for our generation

Since the time I was about nine, I recall my parents telling me that I’ll need a good, steady job in order to purchase a home. Naturally, I was always encouraged to work hard at school and I was rightly admonished for any sign that I might be slacking off. Personal responsibility, hard work and accountability were habits learned early. A few years at Monash and a couple of degrees later, after saving for five years, I was able to purchase my first home. Last week marked two years to the day.

Of course, it is true that not all of us had the privilege of a stable upbringing. I was lucky enough to have supportive parents, but sometimes the option of saving until your late twenties in the comfort of mum and dad’s home is not there. Renting is not a choice for many, but a necessity. But what official advice should we expect? Should our government assure us that they will abolish negative gearing but potentially make the cost of rent higher? Should they splash out handouts subsidised by the taxpayer?

Our treasurer, Joe Hockey, delivered his advice last week, and his simple, candid reality check has been slammed as everything from outrageous, insensitive, out of touch, to even being labelled unfit for office for daring to make such a remark. Hockey was even branded a hypocrite, as some reports published his impressive property portfolio to further insult us, seemingly lost on the fact that Hockey came to Australia from a migrant family and, together with his very successful wife, built his success from the ground up. We should admire success rather than mock it with scorn.

I might add the caveat that I thought Joe was being politically foolish by making such a remark, as obviously getting a generously paid, secure job sounds easy in theory but can in fact be highly difficult. We even have scores of qualified medical practitioners struggling to find placement, and the competition for jobs in a range of highly skilled areas is fierce, with many being left with years of tertiary education and little income to show for it. Undoubtedly, Hockey would have done well to acknowledge this reality after his comments, for surely he is aware that life is not that simple.

But why the outrage? Is our generation really so juvenile that we can’t handle a harsh dose of truth from our politicians? It would seem that Gen Y, a generation so blissfully privileged we are blind to it, would rather our treasurer assure us that the government will step in to help, even more than they do so already.

Such is our sense of entitlement that after travelling to Europe on our Contikis and Top Decks in our twenties that we should naturally expect to replace mummy and daddy’s four bedroom home with a dwelling of our very own in a leafy suburb by the time we are 30, and how dare anyone tell us that we cannot have life that easy.

On The Saturday Age this weekend, the front cover featured a story of a young couple in their late twenties searching for their first home. The headline read The Impossible Dream? Where were they searching? Bayside Melbourne. The problem for many in my generation is that we are unwilling to sacrifice the lifestyle we’ve come accustomed to. We’ve enjoyed living in our parents’ homes in the affluent suburbs, and naturally we seek a worthy substitute in the aspirational streets of Doncaster, or the convenient corners of South Yarra, right on the city’s doorstep. Did it ever occur to us that our parents had to walk before they ran too?

Affordable housing exists, just not where we want it. In Melbourne’s growing West there’s plenty of new developments at a reasonable price, and in the outer eastern suburbs of Mount Evelyn, Coldstream and even Kilsyth costs are not outrageous. Units and townhouses can still be nabbed for around $320,000, but we want something better. Where’s the four bedroom house complete with spare room and outdoor deck? Sorry, but that will have to wait.

Yes, house prices are expensive and it’s not easy. But did our grandparents have it easy? Did our parents just start out with what they have now? Our expectations are removed from reality. We are the children of neoliberalism, and our aspirations are so high that in many cases we refuse to look down.

The fact is that home ownership is not an entitlement. It is the product of hard work. There’s nothing else than can be said. The cold truth is that it’s tough, and being told that it’s tough is an affront to the sense of certainty we crave. The first generation to grow up without a recession is learning that prosperity comes at a cost.

5 Comments on Joe’s harsh reality check for our generation

  1. Maybe the addresses of Joe’s palaces should be made public so the homeless and families on the Public Housing wait list or some of the 750,000 unemployed can forcefully move in a squat!

    • Dale Hughes // June 15, 2015 at 8:05 am // Reply

      That’s just envy politics right there. Hockey and his family worked hard for what they have, and they shouldn’t be attacked for it. Rather, they should be admired.

  2. My parent’s first home was purchased in Kew
    We are not extraordinarily well off but definitely comfortable, and even if I am ale to successfully enter medical school next year (destroying my savings in the process) and come out of seven years of tertiary education (with a debt amassing over 50 grand, I might add), with one of those “Good jobs paying good money” I would not be able to afford a standard house in Kew, even after five years saving (the leftovers from the huge cost of living and renting in or around Melbourne), that is for sure.

    It is a sad reality check that those leafy suburbs that we may have grown up in, which were affordable then, are definitely not for the first home buyer now. It’s a price you have to pay for the privileges we were born into (which I know you love to bang on about).

    However, a two bedroom house, in Mount Evelyn (near where I live) and Lilydale, sold recently at 420,000 and 550,000 respectively. Over half a million dollars for a two bedroom, pokey, kit home in Lilydale. This is a poignant reminder that the housing affordability problem is spreading further and further, with no signs of slowing down.

    Hockey’s comments (the virtual equivalent of a shoulder shrug and an ‘eh’) have not been so inflammatory, for me, because I want a three bedroom in the inner east at the same price may parents paid fifteen-twenty years ago. But more-so because it appears as though our treasurer lacking is the foresight to see that there is a huge problem on the horizon. And without the ability to even see a problem, there will definitely not be a solution. A better politician should have led with his desire to build more houses, stimulate this housing boom he wants, and tell us about all the great things the government will do to actually support the further sprawling of cities which all our infrastructure is currently failing to do

  3. These days I would not be able secure a loan for a unit in any outer suburb. I have two diplomas and a degree. What stings about Joe’s comment is that it implies that the work I currently work hard at is worthless. Thankfully, I bought my unit a few years ago when an old, worn out and pokey unit could be had for $200,000-250,000. It would be difficult to bring up children in a unit like mine, though not impossible. It will take me 30 years to pay off my loan so I’m afraid my pokey and worn out unit is my forever home.

  4. Linda Wilson // June 16, 2015 at 9:11 pm // Reply

    Absolute rubbish. No one is saying this generation wants it all without working for it. They just want a chance to own a home. No one said it has to be big, in an expensive suburb, or to happen easily. Joe hockiings simplistic advice was that if u want to own a home, then get a good job (paraphrasing). The feedback from much of Australia is that it is not that simple, because if it was – EVERY TEACHER, POLICE PERSON, ECT WOULD ALL OWN A HOME!!!! Joe hocking provided NO stats, NO expertise, NO research, NO understanding. How can anyone find his comment sensible?????

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: